The difficulties of conducting ethical trials on puberty-blocking drugs

Professor Julian Savulescu
Gender dysphoria

It was recently reported that a major UK puberty-blocking trial is under investigation. Doctors at a London clinic provided drugs to block the development of puberty in young adolescents with gender dysphoria.

The trial began in 2011. A year after starting the drugs, the young people were apparently more likely to report thoughts of wanting to harm themselves. The worry is that perhaps the treatment they received was causing them to have these thoughts of self-harm and suicide.

One of the criticisms of the study is the design. The study involved giving the drugs to a group of adolescents and monitoring the effects. However, there was no control group.

This makes it hard to be sure whether the rates of self-harming thoughts are related to the drugs, would have happened anyway, or perhaps were lower than they would have been without treatment.